The Storyline
In 2009, a bold diamond heist at an exhibition sets the stage for an intriguing investigation led by Officer Jaswinder Singh (Jimmy Sheirgill). Based on his instincts, he identifies three suspects: Kamini Singh (Tamannaah Bhatia), Sikandar Sharma (Avinash Tiwary), and Mangesh Desai (Rajiv Mehta). Despite his relentless efforts, no convictions are made, and the case fades away from public attention. However, Jaswinder’s obsession with the unsolved crime spans 15 years, driving him to uncover the truth about the audacious robbery.
Themes of Morality and Complexity
The movie delves deep into the human side of its characters, showcasing how circumstances shape both heroes and villains. Much like Akira Kurosawa’s noir films, the story blurs the lines between guilt and innocence. Sikandar’s struggles are heart-wrenching, as the narrative focuses on his hardships. Unfortunately, the film doesn’t explore Jaswinder’s personal downfall as thoroughly, leaving the character arc incomplete.
Pacing and Narrative Style
The film is a slow burn, taking its time to unravel the story. While the non-linear storytelling adds intrigue, the constant flashbacks can be disorienting. Sikandar’s years in the Gulf are rushed, leaving questions about how he and his family managed during this period. The climax, while thrilling, leans on far-fetched twists that might not sit well with all viewers.
Outstanding Performances
- Jimmy Sheirgill: Brilliant as the obsessive officer who loses everything in his pursuit of justice. His transition from a respected cop to a broken man is compelling, though it deserved more screen time.
- Avinash Tiwary: Delivers a heartfelt performance as a man crushed by injustice. His portrayal makes you root for his character.
- Tamannaah Bhatia: Decent as Sikandar’s wife, though her character’s secrets and struggles are underexplored.
- Divya Dutta: Despite limited screen time as Jaswinder’s wife, she leaves a strong impact.
Strengths and Weaknesses
- Strengths:
- Strong performances by the ensemble cast.
- A gripping story that keeps viewers invested.
- Neeraj Pandey’s ability to add suspense and tension.
- Weaknesses:
- Loose ends in the storyline, such as Sikandar’s survival in the Gulf and his family’s struggles.
- The climax feels overly clever and unrealistic.
- Lack of balance in character exploration, with too much focus on Sikandar over Jaswinder.
Final Thoughts
Sikandar Ka Muqaddar is a solid pick for fans of slow-burn thrillers. The film’s exploration of obsession, morality, and the human cost of justice adds depth to the narrative. While some elements feel rushed or underexplored, the excellent acting by Jimmy Sheirgill, Avinash Tiwary, and the cast elevates the experience. Streaming now on Netflix, this is a thriller that keeps you thinking long after the credits roll.
